When you got the new one, did they test the old one? My guess, starter solenoid is bad. AT YOUR OWN RISK, jump across the starter solenoid with a screw driver that has a well insulated handle
. If the starter gets power, then the solenoid is bad. Also check all your fuses and all of you electrical connections.
Do you have an alarm on your Jeep that could have gone bad? The starter disable for alarms is usually installed on the starter solenoid.
Good Luck, electrical gremlins always suck.